Tag Archives: privatize

Stop Lansley’s NHS plans – Evidence seems to suggest Lansley is NOT listening as promised and DOES plan to privatize

22 May

I had planned to write about a variety of things I was interested in on this blog. Just mostly because I enjoy learning and I enjoy writing. Writing helps me to put my thoughts and learning on a subject into a cohesive structure. Plus then it’ll be down on virtual paper so it’s there if I ever wonder again or ‘forget’ or even change my mind. I look back and see where I went wrong and learn from it.

At the minute though all I can do is try to get my head around these NHS reforms.

I’ve actually looked into a variety of international comparison studies and research now. There are pros and cons of each healthcare system in each country plus pros and cons of the methodologies used in each study.

One thing that I believe I have discovered however, is that any claims that the NHS delivers low quality or low value for money are based purely on ideology and are nothing more than political rhetoric.

In fact Lansley has claimed to have evidence a number of times falsely. I’ve read that ‘evidence’ and the researchers actually explicitly concluded that by 2012 that NHS would be ahead of most countries, including France which spent much more money – if it continue as it was.

I’ve detailed that in my letter to my MP, quoting Ben Goldacre’s piece on Lansley’s claims and the peer-reviewed British Medical Journal article that re-assed the ‘evidence’ Lansley had and further confirmed that his assessment was either 1) a misunderstanding on his part or 2) a deliberate attempt at misinformation.

My problem is that when the facts are on your side you argue the facts. It seems that Lansley is straight up purposefully misleading the public, and then I can only conclude that he is up to no good.

Anyway there will be more on that when I’ve finished reading all of this very complicated research(and long, did I mention long? pages and pages and pages long of complicated policy and research documents, I’m not even into policy that much but it seems important that this be something I attempt to understand more deeply…always love a bit of interesting research though tbh…yeah I’m a nerd). I’ll deliver my understanding of it all then.

But right now, I’ve received a very interesting newsletter.

I’m not really one for ‘conspiracy theories’ but evidence seems to be appearing that Lansley isn’t planning on listening during this listening exercise in that slightest and that he does in fact plan on privatizing the NHS. Letters to companies show that he and his top advisers have told private health companies that they can expect “big profits” in the future when we move to a more american ‘insurance based’ style.

There was one piece of research which demonstrated that out of five top countries the UK not only spent the least on healthcare but was top in for quality in a number of categories with America spending more than double the UK on healthcare and landing bottom in quality in a very large number of categories per capita and yet has never been demonstrated to be clear cut top. In fact in all research there are some areas America does well and some it does very very badly – some comparisons demonstrate America far below average in comparisons of 30 countries in certain aspects…America is also one of only two countries in which 100% of people are not covered for health. On top of that only 89% of people who are covered actually receive treatment. This seems bad news as currently 100% of brits are covered by the state and will receive treatment when we need it.

The bottom line is that if anyone claims that an American style system is clearly and demonstrably the way forward they either haven’t looked at the evidence, they don’t understand the evidence or they are lying about it…of course there are pros and cons but the evidence as I currently understand it seems to suggests America’s system is less cost effective and in many areas poorer quality than the NHS…as I said I’ll dig through these studies in more detail later in a more thorough report.

For now, read this…

“When we tell him his plans aren’t working, he doesn’t seem to want to hear what we’re saying.”

Dr Hamish Meldrum, Chair of the British Medical Association, May 2011. 


YouGov research paid for by 38 Degrees members has found that 95% of the public have no idea how to get involved with the “listening exercise”. (1)


Andrew Lansley’s “listening exercise” has been carefully stage-managed. Lots of events have been announced after they’ve finished or shut off from the public – like in Sheffield where local 38 Degrees members couldn’t get in because it was invitation only. But that’s not the only reason it’s a sham – behind the scenes, health officials have been told to carry on with Lansley’s original plans(2)


Doctors, nurses, and patients’ groups have been queueing up to say how dangerous Lansley’s NHS plans are. [3] Last week, the Royal College of GPs said they could “unravel” the NHS. And last Sunday, The Observer revealed that one of Lansley’s top advisers told private health companies to expect big profits when the NHS moves to a US-style “insurance system”.

We can’t let that happen. We all rely on the NHS sooner or later, to take care of us and our loved ones. It’s not perfect, but that’s no excuse for ignoring the advice of the real experts and pushing through these huge, untested changes. To stop these plans, 38 Degrees members are contacting and meeting MPs up and down the country. We’re building a huge petition showing the extent of public concern.

So now let’s put these adverts all over the papers – and make sure everyone knows they can get involved with our growing campaign to stop these dangerous NHS changes.

38 Degrees | Blog | Our ads to stop Lansley’s NHS plans.


NOTES
Quote from Dr Hamish Meldrum: http://www.politics.co.uk/interviews/health/interview-bma-s-hamish-meldrum-$21388805.htm
[1] http://www.38degrees.org.uk/lansley-yougov-poll 
[2] Letter ‘shows pause on NHS reform is stunt’ http://www.thisislondon.co.uk/standard/article-23942461-letter-shows-pause-on-nhs-reform-is-stunt.do 
[3] http://38degrees.org.uk/pages/save-our-nhs-who-is-worried

References are from the newsletter edition by Johnny at 38 Degrees.

Advertisements